Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

I have been waiting over an hour after ordering a burger. I used to love coming here for the food and different variety of beer. Each time it has gotten a little worse.. but never this bad. This will be my last visit.

This was our very first visit here and I was really impressed. The appetizers were WONDERFUL! Hot, fresh and tasty! The waitress knew her menu and her recommendations were spot on after only a couple of questions to what our tastes were. Not only did we love it, they have gained a returning customer. I recommend whether you live there or are coming off I-80, the stop will be worth it. A special shout out to Tamina, our wonderful waitress, who also gained new friends.

Came in with a large group of friends and we were able to be seated rather quickly. Everyone had something different from sandwiches to pizza. Our waitress was very polite and did a great job of getting all of our orders right. Food was great and the price was right.

Very disappointed. Passing through on our way back to NC. Literally got seated and NO ONE came and talked to us. We gave them 12 mins. Didn’t even get a water. One person in the bar and 3 tables. They weren’t understaffed there were about 7 girls literally doing nothing. We could hear them in the back though. That’s pathetic. Walking through and not one person talked to us. We left after 12 mins. That’s beyond our patience. Places close & we don’t have time for poor service. Nope. Don’t want to figure out what their food tastes like or wait 1 hr to get it. Wouldn’t waste your time here. Rude. They didn’t even care when they saw us walk out too. So we came over to copper mill for top notch service.

This place is amazing.. food is deliciously 😋 made with love. Their "Thai Pai" pizza is the one to taste .. definitely recommend a stop over if you're driving through Nebraska. My whole family of 10 really enjoyed.. staffs were super friendly..definitely gonna return for them Pizza 🍕 Try it out guys 👍😄😁

I order the Tuscan Chicken pizza every time I stay at a nearby hotel which is often. No lemon dressing on the top of my pizza, but I got a bowl of dry lettuce. I called to inquire why and was told the pizza was made correctly and everything is on it like it supposed to be. Wow, perhaps some customer service training might need to be in the works. Apparently the cook can’t admit to a mistake which wouldn’t cost the restaurant my future business. It was tossed in the trash. What a total waste of money.

Speg n Meatballs is spicy but has no flavor. Pesto chicken alfredo is bland, has zero flavor. Mozz planks were very good though and our waitress was very nice. The calzone and lasagna was good. We asked that the kitchen be made aware of our bland food in case something was missed in the sauces. They did take care of it on our bill which was very nice.

First time to this location. It feels kinda run down. Bar area is pretty cramped and feels very dark. They were out of 3 of the first 5 mini tour beers I tried to order. Staff seems busy, but not swamped. My server was ok. I love old Chicago, so I will probably come back if in the area, but it would be nice if they were a little better.

Waitstaff was friendly and quick, everyone seemed to be having a good time. The garden salad was fresh and the lettuce was crispy. The calzone wasn't too impressive, it seemed a bit void of ingredients, making it not worth the price. Beer was served quickly and at a perfect temperature.

If I could give 2.5 stars, I would. Three stars is mediocre and two stars is poor. Was really excited to try this place after seeing the amount of google reviews. The outside looks nice however the inside needs updating. The hostess knew We came in before another party (she made eye contact with us and we did not walk in at the same time frame) and proceeded to sit the party first. This is an fyi for the restaurant in however they would like to use this information. Once sat, both sides of the booth were sunken and uncomfortable. Waited about five minutes until someone approached us. Waited a while for our nonalcoholic drinks. We ordered our appetizer and entrees when we ordered our beverages. In an effort to order the correct amount of food, We were told the individual pizza was plate size. We should have asked which plate size they were referencing. I don’t know why we were told it was enough food for adults. We need unsolved mysteries Robert Stack out here because these pizzas were the size of a PH personal pan pizza. Yes, you’re thinking correctly. The ones we got for free in elementary school for the “Book It” program. FYI- the places I’ve experienced usually use this size on the children’s menu. This pizza starts around 12 buckaroos! If you want to build your own pizza it starts at 11.49 and each additional topping is 1.49. Still excited and eager, we waited at least forty minutes for our two personal pan pizzas. I will say my personal pan pizza was pretty good. It didn’t let me down flavor wise but the price and small size overshadowed it. There were other things that happened during our visit such as the wrong order placed on our table, extra sauces that never came, and there were no napkins, other than the one that came with the fork. They were not busy when we ordered. Happy note: the bathroom is clean.