Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

Internet site for Old Chicago says it is open until 11:00 pm. We walked in the door at 10:06 pm after a long day of driving for a pizza. Told by staff that kitchen closed at 10:00 pm. Why even put hours on your internet site if you don’t honor your published hours. BTW, the hours on the door state they’re open until 1:00 am. The young staff still there were clueless about hours, store policies, customer service. Unfortunately this is a recurring theme with many businesses today. If you’re going to be on the internet, publish the correct information. Info that follows asks dining type, amount spent, etc. total waste of time.

I ordered a pick up while traveling out of state. Order was supposed to be ready at 5:19. Waited another 10 minutes inside. I had to ask for napkins and they gave no silverware. I ordered Buffalo wings extra crispy. They were not fully cooked, dry and barely any Buffalo sauce on them. They came with two small pieces of celery which looked really old. The the meatball sandwich looks like you’re getting four meatballs, but it’s actually two cut in half. The meatballs were burnt and just did not taste good. The only thing I liked was the side salad. I would never eat here again. We threw half of the $40 meal we paid for in the garbage! Don’t waste your money!

Well, let's see. Traveling thru and looked like a great place to stop in real quick. Since we are traveling 45 states writing our blog on hotels and restaurants, we peeked into the bar and saw it was vacant other then one customer at the bar. We decided to go into the dining area and grab a booth which I fell into the sinking cushion hole. No biggie, we were one of two tables with customers there. We were never greeted although waitress helped the only Table with a customer who was directly next to us. We gave it 12 min. Zero water, dying of thirst. Decided to take our business elsewhere. By the way this place was FAR from understaffed so not an excuse. I won't be including you in our book or blog. I highly suggest stepping up your service. We ate at 946 resteraunts last year alone, sooo we know when it's a staff issue or other and so on. And I've never walked out of a place. That's saying something.

I just ordered on line and it was $13.65 for 4 slices of nothing! I can not believe that they would charge that much money fora kids pizza! I feel like it would have been better to got to Pizza Hut or Casey’s for that matter for half the price and more food!

Staff was nice and served me even though their kitchen closes an hour prior to their actual close time (which i didn't know as I'm from out of town). That is really the only issue I would have as the people who came after me were rejected food even though the establishment was still open for another hour. I got their hand tossed pepperoni pizza and it was 8/10. They do have a large alcohol selection and I personally only had Dr Pepper soda which I was glad that they carried.

Nice! Food was fulfilling and visually pleasing. Great for the whole family. The bar makes it a nice spot to relax after a long day plenty of options for everyone. Location was easy to find and very close to the interstate.

Loved atmosphere very clean. The music was at the right volume and very universal.There was only one waitress with 7 tables of two or more and she handled it like a champ , she was very personable. The pizza was mighty tasty as well.

Family friendly environment with attentive service. While everyone else at my table enjoyed hearty pasta and pizza, I ordered the grilled chicken avocado sandwich with side veggies and dip. It was fantastic! Perfectly cooked chicken breast and crunchy fresh vegetables. Healthy options are definitely available; the menu should please anyone.

My wife and I both get out of work late and love the fact that old Chicago is open late. 1st of this place is clean and up to date, very family friendly. Staff is polite. On this particular night we decided to get burgers at this place...I love there burgers here. We ordered the crafted beer burger. Was a normal pace night busy for a Thursday night especially at 11pm. We got our burgers and for some reason the burgers were super salty. My wife complained...like always....and I decided to agree like always. We asked for our waiter and she said she would talk to the manager. The manager came out and said they don’t put salt in there steak burgers but he said that the onions are salty so he was very sorry and he said he would remake them. I told him to just remake my wife’s burger and he did. Second burger was great! My wife enjoyed it.

Visited for the first time yesterday and we are so glad we did. Our waitress, Tamina was friendly, professional, and was able to answer all of our questions. All of our food was delicious. So glad we got a chance to try it out!